Concept review new item: public hearing



Download 14.73 Kb.
Date conversion20.02.2017
Size14.73 Kb.


2
ATTACHMENT 4
16 E. CALLE LAURELES - MST 2006-00322


ABR MINUTES July 3, 2006
CONCEPT REVIEW - NEW ITEM: PUBLIC HEARING

3. 216 E CALLE LAURELES E-3/SD-2 Zone

Assessor's Parcel Number: 053-091-011

Application Number: MST2006-00322

Owner: Paula S. Schaefer

Applicant: Paul Poirer

Architect: Paul Poirier

(Proposal for a 1,080 square foot, two-story addition to an existing 743 square foot, one-story, single-family residence on a 6,352 square foot lot. Proposed are a 487 square foot first floor addition, a 593 square foot second floor addition, a second story deck, and a 184 square foot addition to the existing attached 210 square foot garage.)
(COMMENTS ONLY; PROJECT REQUIRES ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND NEIGHBORHOOD PRESERVATION ORDINANCE FINDINGS.)
(4:58)
Present: Paul Poirer, Applicant/Architect.
Public Comment opened at 5:05 p.m.

Caroline Griffith, resident, spoke in opposition to the second-story deck.

Wes Brown, resident, spoke in opposition to the proposed addition size exceeding that allowed in the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions Imposed on Real Property.
Kathiann Brown, resident, spoke in opposition to the second-story deck.
Ms. Brodison summarized various letters received expressing opposition or support for the project.
Public Comment closed at 5:16 p.m.
Motion: Continued two weeks to the Full Board with the following comments: 1) The Board is supportive of the project and finds that the proposed project is a well-conceived, modest, second story addition that blends nicely with the existing structure, and steps back nicely on all sides of the building. 2) The majority of the Board is concerned with the entry element and would like to see further study. 3) The majority of the Board supports the second story deck, but would like to see privacy concerns addressed. In order to evaluate privacy concerns, the Board requests panoramic photos from the second-story showing all adjacent properties. 4) Restudy relocating the second story deck to the front street side.

Action: LeCron/Sherry, 7/0/0.



ABR MINUTES July 17, 2006
CONCEPT REVIEW - CONTINUED ITEM

4. 216 E CALLE LAURELES E-3/SD-2 Zone

Assessor's Parcel Number: 053-091-011

Application Number: MST2006-00322

Owner: Paula S. Schaefer

Applicant: Paul Poirier

Architect: Paul Poirier

(Proposal for a 1,080 square foot, two-story addition to an existing 743 square foot, one-story, single family residence on a 6,352 square foot lot. Proposed are a 487 square foot first floor addition, a 593 square foot second floor addition, a second story deck, and a 184 square foot addition to the existing attached 210 square foot garage.)

(Second Concept Review.)
(PROJECT REQUIRES ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND NEIGHBORHOOD PRESERVATION ORDINANCE FINDINGS.)
(5:33)
Present: Paul Poirier, Architect; Paula and Sam Schaefer, property owners.
Public comment opened at 5:43 p.m.

Greg Mohr, resident, not opposed to the project.

Robert Taylor, resident, spoke in opposition.

Ms. Brodison read into the record the names and addresses of two residents who submitted letters.

Public comment closed at 5:48 p.m.

Motion: Preliminary Approval with the finding that the Neighborhood Preservation Ordinance criteria have been met as stated in Subsection 22.68.060 of the City of Santa Barbara Municipal Code, and return to Consent Calendar with the following comments: 1) The revisions to second floor and second floor deck are enhancements over the previous submittal. 2) The Board is concerned with the roofline of the west street elevation as illustrated. a) Study utilizing a dormer or break pitched roof over the entry element to improve the roof and second story wall intersection, and b) align the garage roof with the roof element over the living room. 3) Provide clarity of the fireplace flue placement in subsequent submittals. 4) The Board is in favor of a small opening on the north face of the deck wall. One suggestion is to utilize a screen type element for privacy yet allow ventilation. 5) The Board supports the materials and colors as presented.

Action: Mudge/Sherry, 7/0/0.








The database is protected by copyright ©hestories.info 2017
send message

    Main page