A symbol is: a thing that suggests more than its literal meaning. Symbols point and hint at meaning, but do not stand for one definite meaning. They are NOT abstract terms like truth or honor. Instead they are noticeable objects.
Some classic examples of symbol are:
The white whale in Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick: as the devil
Locate the exact place in the story where the symbol links itself to the other thing.
Ask whether each symbol comes with ready-made cultural associations. If so, what are these?
Avoid far-fetched interpretations. Focus first on the literal things, places and actions in the story.
Don’t make a symbol mean too much or too little; don’t limit it to one narrow association or claim it summons up many different things.
Be specific. Identify the exact place in the story where a symbol takes on a deeper meaning.
Activity for “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” or “The Lottery”Teaching note: At the beginning of class, students will be provided with a “Quick Write” prompt. They will have 5 to 10 minutes to write their responses, and then 5 minutes to share their responses with a neighbor. Then a few volunteers can share their responses with the class. This generates student thinking, writing, and talking about the subject with low pressure, and can be a jumping-off point for further discussion.
Quick Write Activity: Imagine that you are a citizen who has escaped from either Omelas (in Ursula K. LeGuin’s “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas”) or the town from Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery.” Write about why you left your community, and what you hope to find in the outside world. If someone were to inquire about the place you came from, how would you respond?
Teaching Note: Follow-up Questions
-After activity, review “Elements of Fiction: The Symbol” sheet
-Did anyone write about/make connections with a symbol in their response? (This may have been addressed naturally in discussion)
-These two stories about the behaviors of societies seem similar. How are the symbols in each similar or different?
-How did you decide what was a symbol in one of the stories?